Monday, July 23, 2012

Don't throw the laptops out with the bathwater

I am an ipad fan. I never thought I would be. I caved in to peer pressure (I never thought I'd do that either) when I sat between a fellow AST (@JenniH68) and an ICT adviser (@NorfolkTeachers). They got out their slick ipads, I got out my notepad*. I had complete envy when they started comparing apps, so when I left the meeting I went straight down to the apple store and purchased an ipad 2. I have not regretted it for a moment.

As soon as I had bought it and downloaded a few apps, I could see the huge potential for optimising learning in the classroom. I knew that the school had some money in the ICT budget, so I put in a proposal to our headteacher. He always liked being at the cutting edge of technology, purchasing IWB ahead of the game, innovating with the website and VLE and as a school I believe we were blogging before anyone else in Norfolk. Unfortunately at this point, he had announced his retirement and said it needed to be the new headteacher's decision. I tapped my foot patiently for over a term, frustrated about not being able to be the first school in Norfolk to adopt them.

We finally purchased 45 ipads in the autumn term of 2011 and haven't looked back. The way that they have been used will be written about elsewhere, but you can see how my 2/1 class have used them here and you can find out about the apps we have here.

Don't chuck the laptops!

Much as I love the ipads, I am a firm believer that they do not (and will not) replace laptops. Here's why:

  • Our local high school uses laptops / desktops. Our children need the skills to be able to use them.
  • Visualisers, cameras, dataloggers, digiblues, tuffcams and some control resources are all used with the laptops. Yes there are animating/control apps on the ipads, but we want the children to learn how to use a range of hardwear. 
  • We use a lot of the free resources from the BBC that are flash-based. These will not run on the ipads.
  • Blogging can be easy on the ipads with the blogger app, but you are limited with what you can do on them. It is difficult to upload photos onto some blogs, through the internet, on ipads.
  • We currently write reports using a word based template (though this will hopefully change to an online report writing system
  • We have a range of software on the laptops that the children love to use, including these notable ones:
    • Kodu
    • Scratch
    • Clicker 5
    • Photostory3
    • Windows movie maker
    • Espresso
    • Activprimary
    • Primarygames maths resources (we have 11 different packs).
    • A wide range of Sherston software that supports embedding ICT (Have you seen Flobot? Charlie chimp? Bucket and spade? My year 2/1s love them!)
    • Textease (which helps cover a vast amount of our ICT curriculum)
    • A range of 2simple resources

Also, we have a security system on the laptops to prevent children looking at / doing anything inappropriate. This is not on the ipads. We have not yet mastered saving work to the network either. So as you can see, we definitely won't be ignoring our laptops - they still get used as much (if not more) than our 'beloved' ipads!

*My ipad has not (and will not) replace my beloved Gruffalo notepad either ;-)

*Update on 14.2.2013*
For a more up-to-date post covering this and other matters, take a look at (my good ICT geeky friend) Ant's blog post. His blog will not fail to inspire you when you read some of the marvellous things he has done!


  1. Love this, I agree totally. Love my iPad2 but would not give up my laptop. There are lots of thing as you stated that the iPad does not do and some that it does not do as efficiently as a laptop. Howeve they do provide an instant resource in the classroom that children have adapted to. They are another skill that the children need to be able to use but are not the answer to ICT learning.

  2. That's the thing I love about them-how instant they are. This is why learning has been optimised in my classroom. Children choose to go on them and can have fun with their learning at the touch of a button. Even our new laptops took a few minutes to load, then you have to allow time for shutting down and putting away too.

  3. And this is what is frustrating about the iPads. The previous comment was written on it. I want to make changes and it wouldn't let me. Then it wouldn't let me add to it. I know that laptops can be temperamental too, but I always have blog problems on the iPad, unless I use the app, which does not let me have the formatting options I like. With both options though, I know I have the best of both worlds :-)

  4. Totally Agree! I have tried to convince my peers that the iPad will never replace the laptop. It can not until it install a USB port so that the user can import and export files. But this will not happen because they want us to stay dependent upon the Apple apps. Do I love my iPad? Of course. But I love my PC and Mac laptops just as much. Thanks for this post.

  5. Thanks for your comments Reba. I know that I would be lost without my iPad-I love how portable and intuitive it is, but like you, I would be lost without my laptop too.


Please be patient, your comment will be posted once moderated.